Polyglot Concordance / Mk · Confession and Transfiguration
New Testament · Confession and Transfiguration · Mark

Mark 8 : 29

EN He said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” Peter answered, “You are the Christ.”

ES Entonces él les dice: Y vosotros, ¿quién decís que soy yo? Y respondiendo Pedro, le dice: Tú eres el Cristo.

ZH-HANS 又问他们说:「你们说我是谁?」彼得回答说:「你是基督。」

ZH-HANT 又問他們說:「你們說我是誰?」彼得回答說:「你是基督。」

Mark 8:28
Mark :
Mark 8:30

批判性批注

13 处异文 · 3 处见证
𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
substitution All three attest
Greek NT καὶ αὐτὸς ἐπηρώτα
Peshitta ܐܡܪ
Vulgate Tunc dicit

Greek opens paratactically with καὶ αὐτὸς ἐπηρώτα ('and he himself was questioning'), an imperfect of repeated/ongoing action; the Peshitta reduces this to a simple perfect ܐܡܪ ('said'), and the Vulgate replaces the conjunction with the temporal adverb Tunc dicit ('then he says'), a present-tense narrative rendering. The three traditions thus diverge in both verb of speech and tense aspect.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
expansion Peshitta only
Peshitta ܝܫܘܥ

The Peshitta explicitly supplies the subject ܝܫܘܥ ('Jesus') of the verb of speaking, a clarifying expansion absent from both the Greek and the Latin, where the subject is left implicit in the third-person verb.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
construction All three attest
Greek NT με
Peshitta ܥܠܝ
Vulgate esse

Greek με and Latin me render the object pronoun 'me' directly governed by the infinitive; Syriac uses the prepositional phrase ܥܠܝ ('concerning me'), constructing 'what do you say concerning me that I am', a periphrasis idiomatic to Syriac syntax.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
construction All three attest
Greek NT λέγετε
Peshitta ܐܡܪܝܢ ܐܢܬܘܢ
Vulgate Respondens

Greek λέγετε and Latin dicitis express the second-person plural verb synthetically; the Peshitta uses the periphrastic participle ܐܡܪܝܢ ܐܢܬܘܢ ('saying [are] you'), the regular Syriac analytic present construction.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
construction All three attest
Greek NT εἶναι;
Peshitta ܕܐܝܬܝ
Vulgate dicitis

Greek εἶναι and Latin esse use the bare infinitive 'to be'; the Peshitta renders this with a finite first-person form ܕܐܝܬܝ ('that I am'), introducing a complementiser clause rather than an infinitival construction.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
punctuation Two witnesses
Greek NT αὐτούς·
Vulgate Vos

The Vulgate marks the introduction of direct speech with an explicit colon, where the Greek embeds the high point within αὐτούς·; the Syriac employs no such punctuation token.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
punctuation Two witnesses
Greek NT εἶναι;
Vulgate Petrus

The Vulgate sets the interrogative off with a discrete question mark token, whereas the Greek incorporates it into εἶναι; and the Syriac has no corresponding mark.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
construction All three attest
Greek NT ἀποκριθεὶς δὲ
Peshitta ܥܢܐ
Vulgate ait

Greek and Latin use a participle of answering (ἀποκριθεὶς / Respondens) followed by a connective δέ; the Peshitta renders the same with a finite verb ܥܢܐ ('he answered'), reflecting the Syriac preference for serial finite verbs over participial subordination.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
lexical All three attest
Greek NT ὁ Πέτρος
Peshitta ܫܡܥܘܢ
Vulgate ei

Greek Πέτρος and Latin Petrus give the Greek surname 'Peter'; the Peshitta preserves the original Semitic name ܫܡܥܘܢ ('Simon'), a lexical difference rooted in the underlying Aramaic onomastic tradition rather than the Graecised cognomen.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
construction All three attest
Greek NT λέγει
Peshitta ܘܐܡܪ
Vulgate Tu

Greek λέγει uses the historic present 'says'; the Peshitta adds a coordinating waw ܘܐܡܪ ('and said'), and the Latin ait again employs a defective verb of speech — the three reflect distinct stylistic conventions for introducing the reply.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
punctuation Two witnesses
Greek NT αὐτῷ·
Vulgate Christus

The Vulgate again marks the onset of Peter's direct discourse with a colon; the Greek folds the high point into αὐτῷ· while the Syriac transmits no punctuation token here.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
construction All three attest
Greek NT εἶ
Peshitta ܗܘ

Greek εἶ and Latin es supply the finite copula 'are'; the Syriac uses the enclitic pronoun ܗܘ ('he/is') as a nominal-sentence copula, the standard Syriac construction for predicate identity without a verb 'to be'.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
harmonisation Peshitta only
Peshitta ܒܪܗ ܕܐܠܗܐ ܚܝܐ

The Peshitta appends ܒܪܗ ܕܐܠܗܐ ܚܝܐ ('the Son of the living God'), absent from both the Greek NA28 and the Vulgate at Mark 8:29; this is a harmonisation toward the parallel confession in Matt 16:16 (σὺ εἶ ὁ χριστὸς ὁ υἱὸς τοῦ θεοῦ τοῦ ζῶντος), a well-attested Syriac assimilation of the shorter Markan reading to the fuller Matthean form.