Polyglot Concordance / Mk · Bread, Discernment, and Healings
New Testament · Bread, Discernment, and Healings · Mark

Mark 8 : 4

EN His disciples answered him, “From where could one satisfy these people with bread here in a deserted place?”

ES Y sus discípulos le respondieron: ¿De dónde podrá alguien hartar á estos de pan aquí en el desierto?

ZH-HANS 门徒回答说:「在这野地,从哪里能得饼,叫这些人吃饱呢?」

ZH-HANT 門徒回答說:「在這野地,從哪裏能得餅,叫這些人吃飽呢?」

Mark 8:3
Mark :
Mark 8:5

Critical apparatus

8 variants · 3 witnesses
𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
omission Two witnesses
Greek NT Καὶ
Vulgate Et

Greek opens with the connective Καί and Latin with Et, marking narrative continuity; the Peshitta omits any introductory conjunction here, beginning directly with the verb ܐܡܪܝܢ, a stylistic feature of Syriac narrative which frequently dispenses with the Greek paratactic καί.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
lexical All three attest
Greek NT ἀπεκρίθησαν
Peshitta ܐܡܪܝܢ
Vulgate responderunt

Greek ἀπεκρίθησαν (aorist of ἀποκρίνομαι, 'they answered') and Latin responderunt both render the act of replying; the Peshitta uses ܐܡܪܝܢ from the root a-m-r ('to say'), a participial form expressing 'they say/said' rather than the explicit notion of answering, smoothing the Semitic idiom.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
construction Greek NT only
Greek NT ὅτι

Greek introduces the disciples' speech with the recitative ὅτι (functioning like quotation marks before direct discourse); neither the Peshitta nor the Vulgate represent this particle, the Latin instead marking the speech with a colon and both relying on direct quotation without a complementiser.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
construction All three attest
Greek NT τούτους
Peshitta ܠܗܠܝܢ
Vulgate quis

The demonstrative object 'these' (τούτους / illos) stands early in the Greek and Latin clauses, but in the Peshitta ܠܗܠܝܢ is deferred to near the end of the sentence, reflecting Syriac word-order preference for placing the object after the verbal and locative material.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
omission Two witnesses
Greek NT ὧδε
Peshitta ܗܪܟܐ

Greek ὧδε and Syriac ܗܪܟܐ both supply the locative adverb 'here'; the Clementine Vulgate has no corresponding word, leaving the spatial reference implicit in the prepositional phrase in solitudine.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
expansion Peshitta only
Peshitta ܟܠܗܘܢ

The Peshitta adds ܟܠܗܘܢ ('all of them', root k-w-l) intensifying the demonstrative ܠܗܠܝܢ to read 'all these', an emphatic expansion not present in the Greek NA28 or the Vulgate, heightening the disciples' sense of the impossible magnitude of the crowd.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
punctuation Vulgate only
Vulgate Unde

The Vulgate inserts a colon after discipuli sui to mark the transition into direct speech, a function served in Greek by the recitative ὅτι; this editorial punctuation has no lexical counterpart in the other traditions.

𝔊 grk ℙ syr 𝔙 vul
punctuation Vulgate only

The Vulgate's terminal question mark corresponds to the interrogative force already encoded in the Greek ἐρημίας; (with its question mark) and in the Syriac interrogative ܐܝܡܟܐ; it is a typographic marker of the rhetorical question rather than a textual variant.